RE/MAX Real Estate Professionals | Top Real Estate Office in Columbus, IN

Carrie Abfall

REALTOR®

Text me for more info on any home 812-390-8440

Premier Services

Luxury Home Search

Access homes directly tied to the local area MLS feed. Listings updated every 15 minutes.

Start Your Search

Receive Instant Listing Alerts

Looking for your dream home that checks all the boxes? Get notified as soon as it hits the market!

Subscribe for Alerts

Save Your Favorite Listings

Create an account today to save your favorite listings, take notes about it and more.

Create an Account

Research Local Market Reports

Curious about a local area? Get a detailed report showing historical trends and activity.

Get Your Free Report

Get Pre-Approved for your Mortgage

If you're looking for a mortgage loan or have questions about financing, start here.

Start Application

Unparalleled Service

Your passport to buying and selling the most unique properties.

Contact Us Today
upscale modern kitchen with steel appliances

Complimentary Home Evaluation

Receive an in-depth estimate of your home's value and find out what potential buyers might pay in today's market.

Get Home Value

About Carrie Abfall

Meet Carrie Abfall!!!
Realtor bios are so boring… but here’s the real story.
I’ve been selling homes in Columbus and Central IN since college—Over 25 years of full-time experience rooted in the community I grew up in and still proudly call home. I know every neighborhood. My reach is deep and personal. I’m also a wife, mom, lake lover, and I understand how people truly live in this area.
WHAT: I’m Type A—in the best way. I return msgs promptly because communication is everything in a fast-moving market. I’m a 24/7 advocate for my clients, consistently ranked among the top agents in my office. If you want honesty, strategy, and someone who takes your goals seriously, I’m your person. Ask me what I think—I’ll tell you. I represent all price ranges with equal care. I love first-time buyers, upsizers, downsizers, military families, relocations and everything in between.. Whatever your chapter, I’m skilled at finding exactly what fits your life.
HOW:
I’m super friendly and a great listener—even the things buyers don’t say out loud. As we tour homes, I’m watching reactions, preferences, hesitations, and excitement to help you dial in what truly matters. Behind the scenes, I’m all strategy.
My goal is simple: maximize your property’s appeal and exposure to the best, most qualified buyers—and negotiate relentlessly on your behalf. If buying, I’m neck deep in the comps, the market data, and the strategy to help you score the best home at the best price.
WHY:
I care about my community deeply. My family and I volunteer and financially support many local organizations. My son just graduated college and we have to dog babies (bennie and lucy), and my husband is an engineer. Giving back is part of who we are.
It would be my pleasure to answer your questions, strategize your next steps, or simply talk about what your real estate future could look like. I’m available by call, text, or email—and I communicate often and clearly. 812-390-8440 call or text me anytime! –Carrie