"
Absolutely LOVE working with Carrie! She is very knowledgeable and works very hard to make her clients happy. She sold our last home in a few days, and we wouldn’t work with anyone else. Kind, patient, knowledgeable, gives great insight on things even seasoned buyers/sellers may forget!
"
- Heather Rawlings
"
Carrie is at the top of the list of the best realtors in Columbus! As a mortgage lender, I interact with agents closely to get home buyers across the finish line to Homeownership. Carrie is always a pleasure to work with. She's trustworthy, dependable, and is looking out for her buyers/sellers during all phases of the process. Call Carrie-it'll be the best call you make today.
"
- Maggie De La Rosa
"
"I just wanted to take a moment and thank Carrie for the outstanding job she did selling our vacant lot. It had been on the market by owner and by another company for over 1-1/2 years. Carrie took the listing, and with some creative marketing, was able to sell the lot in less than 6 months! Carrie has a very strong reputation for selling homes quickly in our area. That, coupled with the fact that she is an outstanding person, made it quite enjoyable to work with her over the listing period. She kept us very well informed and offered great suggestions and recommendations that helped us finalize the sale. Carrie will be our agent for any other transactions moving forward! Thank you very much for your hard work and effort to sell this lot for us! It was GREATLY APPRECIATED!!!
"
- Duane Risser
"
During the best of circumstances, selling a house is a stressful experience. We followed her expert advice and sold my Mom’s house very quickly. I loved Carrie’s no-nonsense, straightforward style. I highly recommend working with Carrie to sell or buy your next home. Without a doubt, Carrie sells Columbus!
"
- L Angermeier
"
Carrie not only sold our old house for us, she helped us into the new one! She cares about her customers and listens to what they want. She was happy to walk us through the steps and answer all of our questions! Thanks Carrie!
"
- Courtney Plummer
"
This was my first experience buying a home, and Carrie was beyond helpful. Very prompt with her responses and was always honest about what we were seeing. We ended up in a house we love thanks to her!
"
- Max Kirkland
"
Carrie is the best! She helped us purchase our summer home on Grandview Lake. I was impressed with her knowledge, not only current activity but past. She grew up on the lake so had a lot of information to share. I am confident we got the best deal possible with her impeccable negotiating skills. If we were to buy another house on Grandview, we would certainly be calling her, but we're not going anywhere, we love the lake life. Thanks Carrie!
"
- B Palmer
"
Carrie was exceptional in every way! She totally exceeded our expectations. Her knowledge of the market and Columbus area resulted in us getting the very best price for our home. Highly recommend Carrie!
"
- Ed
"
I worked with Carrie over approximately a six-month period on a project to first renovate and then sell a home. Carrie was very attentive and responsive throughout the project - we agreed on a budget, she presented options, we made decisions together, and she kept things moving forward. I never felt pressured to do anything I didn't want to do and I always felt like the project was progressing at an appropriate pace. Carrie was also great about keeping me informed on timing, market conditions, and the like. Upon completion of the extensive renovations, the house quickly sold for a value I was quite satisfied with. Thanks Carrie!
"
- Steve A
"
It has been a pleasure working with Carrie in selling and purchasing our homes. You demonstrate professionalism in all aspects of your job. You have been very responsive to our needs. You have been very thoughtful in suggesting strategies on the selling/purchasing process in 2020 and 2021.
"
- Jim and Janice Petro
"
Carrie is Awesome - I've dealt with 8 realtors over the last 20 years through several moves and she was by far the best. She really knows Columbus and the market here, providing us advice and options and always keeping us informed. Thank You Carrie!
"
- Rick Davis
"
Carrie helped me buy my first house in 2014. The process went smoothly because she is great at what she does. She was helpful and responsive both during the process and after. Her insights helped me a great deal as I was a first time homeowner. I would recommend her to others.
"
Meet Carrie Abfall!!!
Realtor bios are so boring… but here’s the real story.
I’ve been selling homes in Columbus and Central IN since college—Over 25 years of full-time experience rooted in the community I grew up in and still proudly call home. I know every neighborhood. My reach is deep and personal. I’m also a wife, mom, lake lover, and I understand how people truly live in this area.
WHAT: I’m Type A—in the best way. I return msgs promptly because communication is everything in a fast-moving market. I’m a 24/7 advocate for my clients, consistently ranked among the top agents in my office. If you want honesty, strategy, and someone who takes your goals seriously, I’m your person. Ask me what I think—I’ll tell you. I represent all price ranges with equal care. I love first-time buyers, upsizers, downsizers, military families, relocations and everything in between.. Whatever your chapter, I’m skilled at finding exactly what fits your life.
HOW:
I’m super friendly and a great listener—even the things buyers don’t say out loud. As we tour homes, I’m watching reactions, preferences, hesitations, and excitement to help you dial in what truly matters. Behind the scenes, I’m all strategy.
My goal is simple: maximize your property’s appeal and exposure to the best, most qualified buyers—and negotiate relentlessly on your behalf. If buying, I’m neck deep in the comps, the market data, and the strategy to help you score the best home at the best price.
WHY:
I care about my community deeply. My family and I volunteer and financially support many local organizations. My son just graduated college and we have to dog babies (bennie and lucy), and my husband is an engineer. Giving back is part of who we are.
It would be my pleasure to answer your questions, strategize your next steps, or simply talk about what your real estate future could look like. I’m available by call, text, or email—and I communicate often and clearly. 812-390-8440 call or text me anytime! –Carrie
We have sent an email to . Check your email and click the link to verify your information and view sold listing data on our website. Thank you.
Note: If you don't see an email in your inbox, check your spam folder.
Enter New Email
An account was created for the previously used email. Updating your email here will update that account.
Stay Updated With Your Home Search
By accepting below you agree to our Terms & Conditions
and that real estate professionals from REMAX Real Estate Professionals and lenders may call/text you about your
inquiry, which may involve the use of automated means and prerecorded/artificial voices.
Message frequency varies. Text HELP for help or STOP to cancel. You don't need to consent as a
condition of buying any property, goods or services. Messages/data rates may apply. Additional
information about data use is in our Privacy Policy
Please click the checkbox below
Apply today, your next place is waiting!
Request an application for this rental listing through our trusted partner, Rental Beast, and enjoy the benefits:
One-time Application Fee
Use your application with participating Rental Beast properties for 30 days with no additional cost.
Seamless Application Process
Request an application and begin yours online in seconds.
Soft Credit Check Only
A soft credit inquiry is used and does not impact your credit score.
Fast-tracked Reviews
Quick processing gets you closer to moving day, faster.
Disclaimer: By providing my phone number above and checking this box, I expressly consent to REMAX Real Estate Professionals, directly or by a third party vendor, InsideRE, LLC, acting on REMAX Real Estate Professionals's behalf, contacting me at this number by calling me or sending me text messages, including marketing and promotional messages, using an automatic telephone dialing system, related to our products and services for real estate transactions, even if my name appears on the "Do Not Call" list. Providing my consent is not required to obtain our products or services. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Text HELP for help or STOP to opt out.
Application Request Sent!
Your request to apply has been sent to the listing agent.
If you do not hear back after a couple of days, you can follow up with the agent to confirm they've seen your request sent via email through .